How to Order
Every product is gluten-free, dairy-free, soy-free, and dye-free. Vegan and nut-free options available. Always baked to order — we bake within 24 hours.
How to get your Reynolds Roost order
Fishers pickup, Thursday–Sunday
Fishers pickup begins Thursday, June 18 — preorder now.
10085 Allisonville Rd, Suite 213, Fishers. Pickup hours: from 11am to 1pm and from 2pm to 6pm.
Order by 6pm and your order is ready the next pickup day — orders placed Monday through Wednesday are ready Thursday. Walk in during pickup hours and give your name; your order will be boxed and waiting.
Custom cakes are pickup-only — Fishers — and require a 50% deposit. Three-tier cancellation policy — see custom-cake terms.
Allergen questions? Text or call (317) 864-1872 — every answer comes from Tiffany personally.